The Lies We Tell
By Nicole Mayerhofer
Mike’s Tavern sits on a little corner just behind old Main Street in small town Cedar City, Utah. Festival Town, U.S.A. It’s busy for a Tuesday night. Patrons, adorned in green, have come out on St. Patrick’s Day to join the merriment of karaoke night that happens every Tuesday and Thursday. A brown-haired girl with big, gold hoop earrings sings into the mic on the dancefloor, now a makeshift stage. Amanda and Olivia sit at the end of the bar watching her as she shakes her hips in time with the music. Amanda wipes her sweaty hands on her black jeans. Her pants are covered in patches from her favorite crust punk and ska bands. Olivia doesn’t recognize any of them.
“Is it just me or she really good?” Amanda asks Olivia.
“She’s better than I am,” Olivia says. “Do you want to sing something?”
“Hell no, you can sing by yourself.”
“I am not nearly drunk enough for that,” Olivia says. The bartender, a busty brown-haired woman, hands them two gin and tonics. Olivia slides her card toward her. “Leave it open,” she says. The bartender nods, takes the card, and turns her attention to two men who had been waiting a while. They are wearing green shirts and one has on a green top hat. They try to flirt with the bartender, but she turns them away, too busy to be bothered by their drunk advances. “Mandy, are you okay?” Olivia says.
“Yeah. It’s been awhile since I’ve been around so many people,” she says.
“Yeah, me too.” Olivia takes a sip of her drink. She can feel the warmth of the gin as it washes down her esophagus. The familiar juniper taste is refreshing.
“We need to do this more often,” Amanda says to her.
“Yeah, we do.” Olivia and Amanda are best friends, but between Olivia’s school and work and Amanda’s boyfriend and antisocial complex, there isn’t much time left for the two of them.
“Maybe not with so many people,” she says.
Olivia nods and take another sip. Another singer has taken the stage and attempts to tackle “Don’t Want to Miss a Thing” by Aerosmith. He is struggling. “So Sarah called Jesse while I was with him,” Olivia says.
“She did not, Liv tell me you beat her ass,” Amanda says.
“He answered the phone right in front of me like it was no big deal.”
“Okay, tell me you beat his ass.”
“We had a fight,” Olivia says, “but it wasn’t like that.”
“What happened?”
“He’s just kind of an idiot. If you break up with someone, then that’s it, it’s over. No more. My dad used to tell me that boys and girls can’t be friends. I’m starting to believe him.”
“Ian was that way with Ella,” Amanda says, “But he blocked her number.”
“Boys,” Olivia says. The gin goes down easier now. Olivia’s drink is only half full. “Do you want to go outside to smoke?”
“Sure.” Amanda grabs her plastic cup and takes Olivia’s hand. Olivia leads her through the tight knit crowd to the patio door. It’s cold for March. Amanda shivers.
“Want my sweater?”
She shakes her head, “Let’s just hurry.”
Olivia hands her a cigarette. The smoke rises into the breeze and is carried away. She lights up her own cigarette and takes a drag. She’s not a regular smoker, but put her in a social situation and throw some alcohol in her, and you’d think Olivia had been a chain smoker since she was five. Olivia sees a girl who she’d met at Mike’s a few times before. The girl smiles at her and waves. Olivia returns the gesture. She takes another drink of gin to help chase away the cold.
“Oh my God,” Amanda says.
“What?” Her face is paler than usual.
“Don’t look right now, but I think the guy standing next to the dude in the brown jacket is my dad.”
Olivia takes another drag and slowly turn back towards the patio door. A man with shoulder length salt-and-pepper hair and a green shirt stands with a beer in one hand and a cigarette in the other. His face crinkles when he laughs. He is talking to a curvy, tan, dark-haired woman across from him. His jeans are dirty and faded and his shirt is wrinkled. Olivia turns back to Amanda. Amanda is staring at the fence, she takes a swig of her gin.
“Do you want to leave?” Olivia says.
“No, it’s just weird.”
“Is this the first time you’ve seen him since he left?”
“No, he came into Walmart once,” she says.
“Well what happened?”
“Nothing. He just bought his crap and left. He looks a little different. I’ll have to show you his Facebook when we get inside.”
“Okay,” Olivia says. She tries not to look back at him again and fails. She tries to see traces of Amanda in him. There aren’t any. Amanda is tall and slim with platinum blonde hair. This man has a dark complexion and is about 5’ 10” at the tallest. He has wrinkles, like ripples in sand, around his dark brown eyes. Amanda hisses at Olivia. She looks at Amanda’s green eyes. They are slightly bloodshot. She must not be sleeping well. “What?” Olivia says.
“Liv, stop staring,” she says. They put out their cigarettes. Olivia takes Amanda’s cold hand and leads her back inside. They walk right past the man Amanda thinks is her father. He doesn’t even flinch. They can hear his raspy voice.
“You think they would keep them dogs tied up,” he says.
Inside, they weave their way through the crowd of people standing by the tables watching the karaoke singers.
“I didn’t get a good look at his face,” Amanda says. “Did you?”
Olivia shrugs. They settle back into the bar stools at the end of the bar. Olivia orders them another round of gin and tonics. Amanda pulls out her phone and gets on Facebook. “This is him,” she says as she holds her phone out to Olivia. The man in the picture stares out at her with the same brown eyes as the man outside talking to the dark-haired woman.
“I think that’s him,” Olivia says.
“I think so too. God, he’s such an asshole. I think that’s the girl he took off with. He only likes her because she does drugs with him. My mom would never allow that.”
“You’re mom is so much prettier anyways, I don’t get how men can do that,” Olivia says.
“Because they’re men, at least your dad still talks to your mom.”
“Yeah, Mandy,” Olivia says, “Maybe a little too much.”
___
It’s the weekend and Olivia doesn’t have school. Noel, one of the girls from the apartments across the street, asked her to come over and watch a movie. Olivia didn’t have many friends and Noel seemed like a nice girl.
“I’m not letting you go into that woman’s apartment,” Olivia’s mom says. Her voice is thick and angry with her Polish accent.
“But, mom,” Olivia says, “I never do anything with friends.”
“Sweetheart,” she looks at Olivia with sadness in her eyes, “you’ll understand when you get older.” She pushes her blonde hair back behind an ear.
“You always say that.”
“Olivia,” she says.
“I don’t care anymore. You never let me do anything with anyone. You want me to be just like you, at home with no friends.”
Olivia knew why she didn’t want her to go, but that didn’t stop her from stomping her way to her room and falling face first into her bed in tears. The walls are thin in her house. Olivia had heard her mom yelling at her dad a few months before about Noel’s mom. She was a single mother, slim and blonde. Olivia’s dad had been keeping her company recently, and Olivia’s mom was fed up with it. Olivia remembers hearing her mom cry after her dad slammed the front door and went across the street to Noel’s mom’s apartment. When her mom came into her room that night to tuck her in, she pretended to be asleep, wishing that she actually was. Olivia’s mom kissed her on the forehead and tip-toed out of her room, shutting the door behind her.
___
“Well compared to my mom, he’s an idiot for leaving her for someone like that.” Amanda takes a sip of her drink. “My half sister messaged me the other day. She told me she found our dad and she wanted to reconnect with me.”
“What’d you say?”
“I told her that we maybe met once when we were in diapers. I don’t need her or my dad. He wants to talk to her and not me, that’s fine. I don’t care. Mom and I have done fine without him.” Olivia takes another sip of her drink unsure of what to say. “The worst part about it is no one I know understands how I feel. Ian’s parents are still together, and your parents are kind of together. At least you all hang out. And then, Dana doesn’t even know who her dad is. I’m the only one I know in a situation like this.”
“Sometimes things aren’t what they seem,” Olivia says. She grabs a napkin from the counter and begins tearing it to shreds.
“Or maybe they are,” Amanda says.
___
Olivia’s dad sits in his blue-and-red flannel, holey pajamas at their big oak table in the dining room watching her while she stands at the stove. The toaster pops with a piece of newly toasted wheat bread. She cracks a brown egg over the stainless steel pan. The egg sizzles in response. The sun has just risen and she is still groggy with last night’s sleep.
“Did you burn the toast?” he says to her.
“No,” Olivia says, “I know what I’m doing.”
“You should have waited to toast the bread.”
She grabs a spatula from one of the drawers and flips the egg. The yolk spills open like golden lava. Shit. She tries to rescue it, but it’s no use. After she tries to salvage what she can she grabs a white-and-blue Corelle plate from the cupboard and places the toast in the center. She walks to the fridge for a slice of yellow American cheese and places it on top of the egg to melt. Once she is satisfied with it’s presentation, she scoops the egg onto the spatula and places it on the toast.
“Orange juice?” her dad says after she places the plate in front of him. She goes back to the fridge and grabs the orange juice. After Olivia sits down, her dad folds his big, hairy hands to pray. She does the same, even though she has no food. “Our Father who art in Heaven hallowed be thy name, may thy Kingdom come and thy will be done here on Earth as it is in Heaven. Bless this food and bless this day you have given us. Amen.”
“Amen,” she say. Olivia opens her eyes. Her dad takes his fork and knife with a quivering hand and cuts into his breakfast. His black beard is streaked with white and it moves in waves as he chews. His face twists in disgust. “What’s wrong?” she says.
“I told you the bread would get cold,” he says. “And now it’s soggy. I’m not going to eat this.”
“That’s your problem.” She looks out the window. The sun has fully risen over Cedar Mountain. She can see the rope hanging from the large American Beech tree in the backyard. It swings back and forth in the wind.
“What did you just say to me?”
“Nothing.” She stands up and goes to grab his plate.
“How do you expect me to eat this shit?” He picks up the plate and throws it towards her. Olivia dodges left. She can feel the plate whiz past her right ear. The plate crashes on the wall behind her. Thank God for Corelle. The egg on the toast leaves a yellow trail down the maroon wall. It looks like a giant snail slime. “Look what you did,” he says. “Clean this shit up before you go to school.”
He grabs his cherry wood cane and limps off toward his office. Olivia takes a kitchen rag and begins to scrub the wall hoping that egg yolks don’t stain. Her mom had the good sense to buy Corelle plates, the kind that don’t break, before she decided she needed a break from their family. She still calls all the time, making excuses for why she can’t come back yet. She sounds happier. Olivia glances at the rooster wall clock hanging on the wall above the laundry room door, next to it there is a large wooden cross and a picture of her father in full uniform in Vietnam. He is grimacing. His face is young, but weathered. She scoffs. It’s 7:12, she only has thirty more minutes before school starts.
___
“I want to say I understand, but I don’t.” Olivia watches while Amanda fiddles with the straws in her empty drink.
“I don’t care at all anymore. If I was more drunk, I’d walk up to him and say, ‘Hey dad, how the hell have you been? I’ve been great’.”
“Why don’t you?” Olivia says.
“I don’t want to act like he exists either. I’m glad I’m not drunk.”
“Sometimes it’s better if they aren’t around,” she says.
The man from outside walks up next to Olivia. She can smell his Old Spice aftershave mingling with the smell of cigarettes and beer.
“Can I close out my tab?” he says to the bartender.
“Sure, hon. Can I get your name?”
Olivia listens for a name, but the noise from the karaoke enthusiasts drowns it out. The bartender hands him a card and a receipt. He quickly writes a tip, signs it, and walks back to the woman he was outside with.
“Did you hear his name?” Amanda says.
Olivia shakes her head. “I think I heard Terry, Ellen, maybe? I’m not sure, it’s too damn loud.”
“Did he say Tim Allen?” Amanda says.
“Oh, that could have been it.”
“That’s my dad,” she says. Amanda tips the plastic cup back, nearly finishing the whole thing in a single swig. She burps.
“You’re mom is better off,” Olivia says. “I love your mom.”
“My mom loves you,” Amanda says.
“Of course she does, I’m a delight.”
Amanda laughs. Olivia lets out a small sigh. They sit in silence and finish their drinks. The room around them is busy with the bustle of drunk middle aged men and women. They laugh a little too loud, sway a little too much, and smile a little too often. The room is musty, Olivia inhales the smell of alcohol and sweat. She looks at Amanda. Amanda plays with the ice in her empty cup. “Do you want another one?” Olivia says to her.
“I think we should just go. I’m kind of hungry.”
“Taco Bell?” Olivia says. “The drive-thru is open.”
“Are you sure you’re okay to drive?”
Olivia nods. Amanda’s father is dancing with the woman from outside. He holds her tightly and smiles a lazy grin. She is wearing a tight green dress and black, slouchy stiletto boots. The kind that older women wear because they think it makes them look sexy. Amanda stares at them for a moment then looks away. “Maybe I want another drink,” she says. “Do you want one? I’ll buy this time.” She goes to signal the bartender.
“Not if I have to drive,” Olivia says.
“You’re right,” Amanda says. “Let’s just go.”
Olivia asks the bartender to close out her tab. The bartender hands her back her card and the receipt. Olivia leaves her with a tip and her signature. Olivia grabs Amanda’s hand and leads her past her dad and the woman he left her mom for and out the door. She doesn’t let go for a while. The moon illuminates the full parking lot, reflecting off the rooftops of the cars. Olivia’s silver Toyota is the furthest car away. The night has gotten cooler and their breath is visible in the night air.
“You think it will snow again?”
“God, I hope not,” Amanda says. “It’s March for Christ’s sake.”
“Yeah, but it’s Utah,” Olivia says. She shrugs. “Want to smoke again?”
“Sure.”
Olivia hands her another cigarette and they light up. Amanda sits on the ground between Olivia's car and another, hiding from the chilling breeze. Olivia leans against her door and looks up at the stars, trying to find the Big Dipper.
“At least this is one nice thing about Utah,” Olivia says. “You can always see the stars.”
“So what are you going to do about Sarah?” Amanda says.
“Nothing,” she says. “I don’t even care anymore.”